Wednesday, September 5, 2012

Time to go vertical?



Delta and a case for vertical integration
What do you do when you do when your revenues are up, the company has gone into the black after a few bad years during the recession, but one expense item has increased by 32% and now accounts for 36% of total operating expenses? 

Delta faced this question and decided to take a risk and go vertical.
                
In April of this year Delta announced an agreement to purchase (via a subsidiary named Monroe Energy)  a failing refinery in Trainer, Pennsylvania with aspirations to produce jet fuel for Delta's fleet. The cost of the refinery is $180 million (the state of Pennsylvania has pledged $30 million in assistance) and once retrofitted will produce upwards of 80% of domestic fuel required by Delta as well as reducing the total fuel cost by $300 million.[1]  The upgrades to the plant are expected to cost around from $100-350. [2] 
The reduction of $300 million is a reduction of the total cost of $11.783 Billion as of 2011:

From: Delta Air Lines Annual Report: 2011 [3]

The risk, however, lies in an airline running a refinery. This is especially worrying as the refinery that Delta took over was failing. [4] Yet, by the time of the purchase jet fuel prices had already increased another 6% more than the same time last year.[5] It is too early to tell if this risk will pay off but securing their own supply of jet fuel has the potential to change the way airlines approach their supply of fuel. The airlines will be integral to the fuel's production, delivery and pricing. This could be the difference in such a competitive market as the airline industry.

Questions:
  • What conditions do you think were necessary for Delta to even consider purchasing its own refinery?
  • Is this situation replicable in the greater airline industry? Other industries?
  • What differences do you foresee in the supply chain management between Delta's airline operations and this refinery?
  • Are there other aspects of the airline industry that can be vertically integrated?


[1] Mouawad, Jad. "Delta Buys Refinery to Get Control of Fuel Costs." New York Times 30 Apr. 2012: Web. 4 Sept. 2012. <http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/01/business/delta-air-lines-to-buy-refinery.html>.
[2]  Credeur, Mary Jane, and Edward Klump. "Delta to Buy ConocoPhillips Refinery for $180 Million." Www.bloomber.com. N.p., 1 May 2012. Web. 3 Sept. 2012. <http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-04-30/delta-air-said-to-near-accord-to-acquire-conocophillips-refinery.html>.
[3] Delta Air Lines Annual Report 10-K 12/31/2011: Accessed 9/3/2012: URL: http://images.delta.com.edgesuite.net/delta/pdfs/annual_reports/DeltaAirLines_10K_2011.pdf
[4]  Mouawad. 
[5] Credeur and Klump 

Tuesday, September 4, 2012

Product Design in Operations Management: An Overview

Looking for this week's post I found this other blog with a very relevant content for the class. Basically explains very easily why product design is relevant for supply chain management.

The two basic steps in designing a product are functional design and production design and the post goes a little further on these two stages.

In production design there are some concepts that come into play like standarization, modular design and/or simplification.

Finally, the post mentions some of the factors that affect costs during the production design stage besides the direct labor and material costs. 

I hope this is useful.

(August 27, 2011). Product Design in Operations Management: An Overview. Help with Assignment Blog. Retrived on 09/04/2012. Available at: http://helpwithassignment.blogspot.com/2011/08/operations-management-product-design.html

How is Apple winning the price war?

Apple is little known for its price strategy among consumers than its brand.
I summarized below some examples of Apple’s competitive pricing:
1) Apple accepted handset subsidies from carrier partners, therefore reducing the cost of iPhone to a couple of hundred dollars.
2) Apple priced its iPad @$499 plus. As per John Gallaugher, an associate professor of information systems at Boston College, “ It was a very competitively priced device”.  Its biggest competitors could not undercut the prices for a long time.[1]
3) Apple has been aggressively pricing its Macbook Air and Notebook to increase its market share.
It uses the following ways to defend its pricing:
1) Price Decoys: Apple uses some of its products as decoys or reference to encourage customers to buy its other more expensive products. For example $499 iPad looks much better when compared to its cheaper cousin, which is priced at $399, because of enhanced capability.
2) Establish a high reference point: Apple has creatively used the concept of “SALE”. It introduces its products at sky high prices and then rapidly cuts prices, letting the consumer believe that the purchase is a steal!
3) Bundling: Apple is a perfect example of bundling. It bundles the hardware and software components. It sells hardware at a cheaper price only to realize profit by software/application sales [3].
But, as per Bloomberg, New York times and Forbes research the most significant tactic to consider is Apple's supply chain management:
We have known Apple for its cutting edge technology, for its stylish products, for its brand and community. Few of us know Apple for its ingenuity in supply chain management . 
As per Matthew Davis, a supply-chain analyst with Gartner, “They have a very unified strategy, and every part of their business is aligned around that strategy”. He has consistently ranked Apple as the world’s best supply chain for 4 years since 2008 [3].
Apple’s supply chain management tactics began in 1997 when Steve Jobs bought all the available holiday air freight space to ensure timely delivery of iMacs during Christmas. This locked capacity resulted in denied air transport for rival  Compaq. Apple also used air transport to ship music players from China to consumers in US. It covered the overhead of air transport by volume of sales. [2]
Off late Apple has been spending millions of dollars in locking manufacturing capacity. It is using the scale of manufacturing to cut down costs for critical parts.  We discussed in class about how companies were traditionally vertically integrated example Ford and then came the era of decentralization of supply chain and now companies are again moving towards vertical integration, example Apple.
 “According to Katy Huberty, an analyst at Morgan Stanley ( MS - news - people ), that’s exactly what CEO Tim Cook, an operations expert who has been the master of Apple’s supply chain since Steve Jobs hired him in 1998, is doing. And she calls the move “frankly ingenious.” Says Huberty: “Apple is cornering the market in [its] supply chain … giving them an edge beyond volume and scale. If Apple owns its equipment, it means its suppliers can’t build an HP PC or HTC smartphone on it.” [4]
Refer the diagram below to understand the scale of Apple’s investment.


Apple is pumping money in Asian markets to secure production capacity and ability to drive out its competition. It is doing this by buying production equipment  for its suppliers, hiring labor and running day to day operations. As per the article in Forbes magazine[4], for the suppliers of NOKIA, Motorola , HP and Dell, Apple takes out the volatility in their business by soaking the equipment risk and bearing the depreciation costs by owning it. It’s a win-win situation.
“By Huberty estimates, Apple’s investment in supply chain can lead to a 15 to 20% cost decline in per year.” It will also allow Apple to venture into new low margin, high volume markets like Television.  It also gives Apple an opportunity to cut down costs for its existing products like iPad and iPhone and maintain its dominant market share. [4]
Some questions to consider:
Will apple's strategy limit the disruption in technology by denying access to resources to competitors? Will it lead to a monopoly which Will impact the choices available to consumers?
SOURCES:
[1] Apple’s Lower Prices Are All Part of the Plan, By NICK WINGFIELD Published: October 23, 2011
[2] Apple's Supply-Chain Secret? Hoard Lasers, By Adam Satariano and Peter Burrows on November 03, 2011
[3] Little Known Secrets of Apple’s Pricing Strategy, By Dave Bui / April 3, 2012
[4] Apple's Secret Plan For Its Cash Stash, By Connie Guglielmo, 04.20.12, 10:00 AM EDT Forbes Magazine dated May 07, 2012

Procter & Gamble Digital Innovation in operations

McKinsey’s Quarterly recently interviewed P&G CEO Robert McDonald about the nature and progress of the company’s digitization initiative. An edited summary of the interview follows to show the implications that this digital innovation has had in their supply chain.

From factory to shelf
From an operational standpoint, Procter & Gamble believes that to be successful we’ve got to continue to improve productivity, and being digitally enabled allows for that as well. So we’re digitizing our operations everywhere—from our manufacturing plants to the stores where consumers purchase our products. We believe digitization represents a source of competitive advantage.
In our manufacturing plants, for example, we have systems that allow people to use iPads to download data off the production line in real time and communicate that to a place where we roll the data up. We’re not there yet, but we envision a system where I could literally see, on my laptop, any product at any moment as it goes through the manufacturing line of any one of our plants. And what I’d love to be able to do is see the costs of that product at the same time. It’s challenging because accounting systems aren’t designed today for operations—they tend to look backward—but we’re working on integrating our operational system with the financial system to move in that direction.
In transport and logistics, we created a digitally enhanced operational program we call Control Tower that lets us see all the transportation we’re doing: inbound, outbound, raw materials, finished product. We’re probably the second- or third-largest user of trucks in the United States, and through this technology we’ve been able to reduce “deadhead” movement1 by about 15 percent. This reduces costs and carbon monoxide. In circumstances where we use distributors, a similar interface, called Distributor Connect, lets us link directly with them and help them run their business. This benefits all of us by improving service and reducing inventory across the supply chain.
We want to be digitally connected to retailers too. For example, we use and support GDSN,2 which is basically a standardized data warehouse that allows us to do commerce with our retail partners in a totally automated way, with no human intervention. The industry association GS1 did a study a few years ago that found that 70 percent of orders between retailers and suppliers had errors. But if everyone used a common data warehouse like GDSN—where the data are kept dynamically correct—that number goes down to virtually zero, and it saves millions of dollars in doing commerce together.
Another thing we do is to use our scale to bring state-of-the-art technology to retailers that otherwise can’t afford it. Imagine a small store in the Philippines, for example—a country where I used to live. We can provide sophisticated ordering applications to help people there run their businesses better than they would be able to otherwise. We have mobile-phone applications that allow retailers to order from us wirelessly or, if they don’t have a wireless capability, to order when they go back to their office and set the phone in a base. It’s very easy to use.
We also have performance standards that retailers in developing markets can visualize on their phones. For example, we believe you should arrange your store in a certain way to maximize consumer sales. If you have a store that partners with P&G on this, you can call up the performance standards on your phone, hold it up, look around your store, and compare it with what you see. Eventually, I want to be able to take a picture of the shelf, have it digitally compared, and then automatically send action steps back to the retailer to help rearrange the shelf for maximum consumer sales. That’s where we’re going.
In fact, some applications like these will probably come back to the developed world as improvements because they’ll be simpler—there’s no question that progress will be accelerated by the leapfrogging of technology. Inevitably, everything’s got to be usable on the smallest, cheapest device possible because that’s what’s going to get the broadest distribution in a developing market.
Digitizing innovation
Data modeling, simulation, and other digital tools are reshaping how we innovate. The way we used to do innovation research required a lot of work and time setting up consumer panels—you need the right distribution of races, ages, and so forth to make them representative. Now, with the amount of data we have available, the “n” is so large that by definition we can immediately have a representative group.
When you design a disposable diaper the traditional way, for example, by the time you get to the point where you make a prototype, the prototype itself has cost thousands of dollars, if not more, and it was all made by hand. Now, using modeling and simulation, you can go through thousands of iterations in seconds. The key is that you’ve got to have the data. So the advantage for P&G is our scale. We have operations in around 80 countries, our products are sold in almost every country, and we touch more than four billion consumers every day. Imagine all those data points. We can literally fit any virtual diaper to any baby anywhere in the world.
virtualization picture

P&G’s ‘virtual wall’ uses multiple projectors to simulate store shelves for faster consumer testing.
We’re even digitizing the creation of molecules. For example, in the research and development for our new dishwashing liquid, we used modeling to predict how moisture would excite various fragrance molecules so that throughout the dishwashing process you get the right fragrance notes at the right time. We did that all virtually.
I think that digital technology will even help us identify new service components to our consumer products that wouldn’t otherwise be immediately obvious. For example, say you’re a consumer concerned about the environment. You go to one of our packages and photograph the QR3 code. We then could download for you all the ingredients in the product and their biodegradability—or tell you where the product was produced, the quality of the water, or how we’ve reduced carbon emissions in the plant. We can’t do that today, but it’s an aspiration.
Question:

Technology is a tool to be used in dynamic processes and systems but if these are not working correctly, then technology will not solve them so, I was wondering what makes the difference? Innovating in products that are more adaptable to changes in the supply chain in a globalized constantly changing world, or innovating directly in supply chain management to make it more flexible and avoid jeopardizing sales?

References:
Chui, M. & Fleming, T. (November 2011). Inside P&G’s digital revolution. McKinsey Quarterly. Retrieved 09/03/2012. Available at: https://www.mckinseyquarterly.com/Inside_PGs_digital_revolution_2893

Jianghong, G. & Hongzhong, Z. (2010). Product Innovation Management Analysis Based on Supply Chain Management. Retrieved 09/04/2012. Available at: http://www.pucsp.br/icim/ingles/downloads/papers_2010/part_4/1_Product%20Innovation%20Management%20Analysis.pdf

The Changing Nature of Innovation in a Globalized World

Industry and organizations have discovered the importance of supply chain management to the bottom line and are working to find the correct balance for their needs. How will innovation in a global world factor into that balance to different ends? 

In the article Learning from Tata's Nano, the author discusses how "[e]merging markets are a fertile ground for innovation."[1]  Part of the genius of the supply chain of Tata Motors lay in how they farmed the innovation of their distributors and customers. Similarly, in the interview with Charles H. Fine explaining the design of the value chain, Fine discusses how Proctor & Gamble have successfully used open innovation over both zero-sum and win-win value chain architecture.[2] 
 
From these two articles, innovation seems to be one piece of the puzzle where developed countries will have to compete where in the past they might have had a significant advantage. With globalization as a main influence of future supply chains[3], innovation could be something developed countries choose to outsource.

The outsourcing of innovation is not a new concept. Organizations hire consultants, hold contests and reach out for new ideas. From a survey of 359 U.S. based companies, the outsourcing of innovation is most successful when organizations strive for the following circumstances: 1) the innovation is centered around a concept or method with which the organization has little prior experience; 2) the innovation is in its early and uncertain stages; 3) the innovation is in an area with little intellectual protection; and 4) the organization has a great deal of experience outsourcing.[4]

But what does this mean in an increasingly globalized world, and what will the downsides be for both developed and developing countries? As explored by Catherine Mann at the Peterson Institute for International Economics, some of the negatives for developed countries such as the United States include "fewer innovations tailored to our domestic needs and local demand", incomes going overseas, and a decline in our entrepreneurial spirit.[5] However, the outsourcing of innovation must also bring greater collaboration and ideas from across the globe.

These decisions have implications for an organization's approach to innovation. As was related many times in the readings, there is no 'one-size-fits-all' solution, but with an increasingly level playing field, domestic organizations must consider the challenges and opportunities of no longer being the most capable of capitalizing on innovation. 
  
[1] Hagel, John, and John Seely Brown. "Learning from Tata's Nano." Bloomberg BusinessWeek. 26 Apr. 2010: 51-53. Print. 
[2] "Your Next Supply Chain: Interviews with David Simchi-Levi and Charles H. Fine." MIT Sloan Management Review. Winter 2010: 76-80. Print. 
[3] Ibid. 
[4] Stanko, Michael , Jonathan Bohlmann, and Roger Calantone. "Outsourcing Innovation ." Business News & Financial News - The Wall Street Journal - WSJ.com. N.p., n.d. Web. 4 Sept. 2012. <http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970204488304574426521384198990.html>. 
[5] Mann, Catherine L. "The Globalization of Innovation and Entrepreneurship." Ewing Marrion Kauffman Foundation. N.p., n.d. Web. 4 Sept. 2012. <www.kauffman.org/research-and-policy/globalization-of-innovation-and-entrepreneurship.aspx>.

Plumpynut's Supply Chain (+ Peter Drucker)

written by Whitney Coble

Last year, in Professor Zak's Foundations of Social Innovation course, we learned about Plumpynut, the most common RUTF (Ready to Use Therapeutic Food) used by UNICEF to treat children with Severe Acute Malnutrition (SAM).  Plumpynut is an oil-based paste of peanuts, sugar, and milk powder.  It is especially used in the Horn of Africa (i.e., Kenya, Somalia, Ethiopia) where malnutrition is widespread.  The story behind this "magic bullet" is a fascinating one, and you can learn more about Plumpynut from this story Anderson Cooper did on it.  

For the purposes of this week's lesson, I learned about Plumpynut's supply and demand and its supply chain.  

Currently, Nutriset is the single dominant world supplier for Plumpynut.  At the end of 2008, demand for Plumpynut matched Nutriset's capacity to produce.  Worldwide demand is expected to grow by 30% per year, and Nutriset intends to double its production capacity.  However, this is not enough - Plumpynut needs other manufacturers, such as American NGOs or corporations, to meet its demand.  There are a number of obstacles standing in the way: patent protection on Plumpynut's product and production process until 2018, reliance on international sourcing of inputs, logistical difficulties in scaling up production (i.e., raising capital funds, procuring equipment and securing contracts).

Plumpynut's supply chain is currently as follows:
1. The Ministry of Health/NGO partner identifies a specific need for SAM children in the area.
2. Assesses how much Plumpynut is needed and relays information to the UNICEF country office or the Ministry of Health and then UNICEF
3. Emergency orders are shipped via airfreight within a few days.  Non-emergency orders are shipped via sea freight.
4. Most Plumpynut is made in France by Nutriset. Usually, Nutriset delivers Plumpynut within one week of purchase order.  Once Plumpynut is manufactured and packaged, K& N (a global logistics supplier) delivers it to Le Havre for sea freight and Paris for air freight.
5. It is transported from the port of arrival by local logistics suppliers and distributed by implementing partners in the country.  For example, in Kenya:  it is arrives in Mombasa, it will clear customs and be transported by truck to the UNICEF warehouse in Nairobi and will be released to the District Nutrition office or NGO partners.  If it is sent to Somalia: it will be held at bonded in-transit warehouse in Mombasa until a local freight forwarder can move it to Somalia, usually by sea.

Supply chain problems include poor road conditions and security concerns; data not kept or written down with paper and pencil; irregular funding; and variable lead times, causing the cost of transporting from France to Africa to increase.

A team at UNC/Duke, working on behalf of UNICEF, offered the following suggestions in a 2008 report to improve Plumpynut's supply chain: 

• Begin producing Plumpynut regionally and in individual countries at risk, thus reducing the cost of delivery and speeding up delivery
• When shipping, ship by sea to avoid higher costs of air delivery
• Locally, provide drivers with cellphones and rapidSMS, a low-cost, easy-to-understand way of reporting delivery and inventory
• Call upon funders to underwrite the depoting of buffer stocks to speed delivery in emergencies and avoid stockouts
• Improve data collection by asking countries to use simple spreadsheets, examine climate forecasts for 

threat of drought, and share data with manufacturers

As a result of their report, the number of suppliers increased from 1 to 14; costs went down thanks to local production; UNICEF increased the volume of its shipments by more than double while bringing 

costs down 10%; and delivery times were shortened.

So what does all of this have to do with our lessons for the week?  The articles we read raised the following questions for me in relation to Plumpynut:

1. Similar to the model IKEA uses, could competition be raised among local trading markets?
2. If a higher purchasing commitment from the U.S. government provided high volume incentives, could cost-saving technology and equipment be added to increase supply chain efficiency?
3. In line with P&G's strategy, can Plumpynut put in place a better system to assess daily demand?

----------

On a completely different note, I wanted to learn a little more about Peter Drucker this week.  The following are three key facts that I learned:
* He won the Presidential Medal of Freedom in 2002.
* His 1954 book The Practice of Management was voted the 3rd most influential management book of the 20th Century.
* Asserted that companies work best when they decentralized.

How it gets there

I spent a little while in the Philippines, a country beset with typhoons, floods, and washed out roads.  During a visit to a mountainous area where it was difficult to get people let alone building materials, I wondered how do they get large amounts of items from here to there.  Certainly over the period I spent in the country I knew how everyday household items and food in its rawest forms traveled from one place to another.  Furniture was not much different.  There is no IKEA in the Philippines, furniture is pre-built, ready for installation and available at the nearest market area.  My own furniture was delivered the usual way, via truck.

Vehicles were often loaded heavily with people and or things.  The IKEA concept of flat packaging to transport items to the store and also to the purchaser's destination has value that I can see being useful in the Philippines.  Difficulty however would be the weight of shipments that IKEA uses in order to maximize shipping costs, particularly outside of Manila in the provinces where roads have weight restrictions and may have one lane bridges.

Certainly supply chain management is not lost on government, business or academia.  In the last five years the Philippine Management Review has published two articles written by Ma. Gloria V. Talavera discussing 1) the applicability of SCM and  2) a survey of supply chain operations in the Philippines.

My intent over the next several weeks is to figure out how to get it there with a focus on logistics.

 

Supply Chain for Digital Goods



In the last class, our focus was on understanding what supply chain management is. It was interesting to discuss how companies like Dell, Wal-Mart and Cisco used supply chain management to give them strategic advantage over their competitors.

As the discussion moved on, my mind kept coming back to how the same concept applied to some new products of the digital age, such as electronic books, audio books and digital music sales online. Traditional supply chains are indeed complex structures, over large geographical locations but are they also complex for digital goods?

We discussed the following strategic supply chain decisions that companies need to take:
– Locations and capacities of facilities
– Products to be made or stored at various locations
– Modes of transportation
– Information systems

The question I would like to address today is that do these decisions apply to digital products? Does the producer need to decide where he wants to sell his e-book or it is assumed that he will do so online? Does the concept of inventory management apply at all? Does the product need to be transported, other than being available to download from the Internet? Is there a need for setting up a separate information system to enable the process or is an e-commerce website enough to cater to this?

The fact that there is no inventory makes digital products an interesting and attractive business opportunity. Whether you sell one unit or a thousand units, the inventory and production need not be worried about. Moreover, accessibility is not an issue. The remotest of areas in the world can be accessed, provided they have Internet access.

Essentially, the supply chain model we studied for physical goods needs extensive modification.



Observe the snapshot of the slide we studied. For an e-book, the producer needs a ‘New Product Strategy’ and a ‘Marketing Strategy’, however, there is little a supplier can do to modify the supply chain strategy. There may be some requirement of ‘Services’ as well, but it will certainly not be as elaborate as the traditional supply chain. Hence the new model would become:
New Product Strategy > Marketing Strategy > Distribution

It is common knowledge that the Internet has facilitated the starting of many businesses by cutting various costs. We can see that most of the cost cutting can be attributed to the supply chain management and the producers can completely focus their energies on the product development and marketing it. Since the product is digital, even the marketing channels are narrowed down to Internet and mobile applications advertising to reach out to the relevant market.

Upcoming Surge in Domestic Manufacturing

Critics of globalization frequently highlight outsourced manufacturing jobs as its most negative aspect. Better technology and communication allowed for a boom in international trade, including the capacity for corporations to make or buy components for their products abroad. When President Obama asked Apple CEO Steve Jobs how to bring some of those jobs back to the United States, Jobs told him "those jobs aren't coming back." [1] Fortunately, there are numerous reasons to think that this trend is going to change. Consider the following:







Source: http://articles.businessinsider.com/2011-10-21/politics/30305267_1_president-obama-political-ads-morning-in-america-ads

Supply Chains

The international supply chains that enable this global economy are essential to reversing some of the job losses caused by the very same system. Many complex products, like Apple's iPhones, are assembled from components made or purchased all over the world. However, rising logistics costs (especially transportation costs) are likely to encourage corporations to set up shop closer to their consumers or their suppliers, if not both. [2] Combined with issues of risk to the durability of supply for specialized producers abroad, corporations that sell high-tech products are going to want reliable suppliers who are closer to their intended markets and can replicate crucial parts of the supply chain in dire circumstances. In fact, this is already happening with Apple, whose CEO considered it almost impossible less than two years ago. The entire iPhone will never be made in the United States, but at least some of its parts are and will be domestically produced. [3]

Product Changes

The resiliency of a supply chain is critical to the continued production of an item when disaster strikes. Transportation costs are on the rise because of unending instability in the world's leading oil producing region. In the mold of IKEA or India's Tata Nano car, products are being more modular and being shipped to their sales destination before being assembled. [4][5] Why do all of these points come together? They converge because we live in a world that expects almost instant gratification and customizable options to boot. Consider custom computers: you can have a computer built to your specifications and have it arrive withing days. That kind of arrangement is not possible without substantial inventory or domestic manufacturing. As sellers seek to rein in costs, increase profits and maintain competitive options for their customers, they will be look to domestic producers for speed and reliability.

Economics

The primary reason for outsourcing jobs is to utilize cheaper labor abroad. Cheaper labor reflects lower productivity, but we would expect both labor costs and productivity to increase over time from technological increases and knowledge gained from such production over time. Is this happening? Yes, and when you combine the start of that trend with the spike in logistical costs, you can see how manufacturing will start returning to the United States. Raymond Sjolseth, President of Seesmart Inc., says "When we do the numbers we're actually ahead manufacturing here instead of paying for air freight and dealing with the logistical issues that we're having in China."  [6]

Summary

In the short-term, globalization drove many manufacturing jobs out of the U.S. Now, the supply chains that support globalization are a key part of the impending return of some of those manufacturing jobs. What can national policymakers do to encourage this process. More importantly, what will they do?

Sources

[1] "Barack Obama and Steve Jobs argued over outsourcing." The Economic Times, January 22, 2012. <http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2012-01-22/news/30652794_1_apple-founder-steve-jobs-barack-obama>
[2] "Your Next Supply Chain." MIT Sloan Management Review, Winter 2010.
[3] Hughes, Neil. "Made in America: Apple's supply chain increasing US production." Apple Insider, July 19, 2012. <http://www.appleinsider.com/articles/12/07/19/made_in_america_apples_supply_chain_increasing_us_production.html>
[4] Margonelli, Lisa. "How IKEA designs its sexy price tags." Business 2.0, October, 2002.
[5] Brown, John Sealy and John Hagel. "Learning from Tata's Nano: The innovations of the $2,500 car carry important lessons for Western Executives." Bloomberg Businessweek, 27 February, 2008.
[6] Malone, Scott and Ernest Scheyder. "As China costs rise, technology lures U.S. factories home." Reuters, July 24, 2012. <http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/07/24/us-usa-manufacturing-onshoring-idUSBRE86N05M20120724>

Emerging Markets Foster Product and System Innovation


In a special report on innovation in emerging markets issued in 2010, The Economist published an interview with their Management Editor, Adrian Woolridge, highlighting the changing nature of global business innovation.


His primary message is that emerging markets have shifted from a cheap labor destination to a source of competition among multinational companies all striving to reach large populations of potential buyers. He compares this current trend to Japan’s development of lean manufacturing in the 1980s as a way to beat out American auto manufacturers. The Japanese were able to beat Americans on price, reliability, and speed of new models to market not through “industrial policy or state subsidies…but [through] business innovation.”[1] This concept applies to what we have been reading about Ikea’s product design and delivery model[2], as well Tata’s Nano. Both of these companies are “competing on price by streamlining the supply chain and challenging conventional wisdom.” Additionally, both Ikea and Tata Motors have designed products and delivery systems by integrating greater modularity into their supply chain and distribution strategies.[3]

Woolridge argues that both the challenges and opportunities to competing in emerging markets are enormous. Dispersed rural populations and variable infrastructure represent major hurdles, while the sheer number of potential customers serves as an enticing draw to enterprising multinationals and ambitious regional companies alike. They realize that, in order to take advantage of these opportunities, they must come up with “smarter ways of designing products and organising processes to reach the billions of consumers who are just entering the global market.[4]” Target customer strategy must reach beyond the global elite and focus on developing and maintaining appeal among rising middle classes. Woolridge argues that this will require a new approach to product development and supply chain systems.

As the emerging world continues to make growing contributions to product and supply chain innovations, the conventional view of globalization as a Western imposition on developing countries is changing. The balance of economic power, too, is fluid as new consumers create unprecedented demand for new products and services worldwide. 
Source: http://www.economist.com/node/15879369
Source: http://www.economist.com/node/15879369

[1] "The World Turned Upside down." The Economist. The Economist Newspaper, 15 Apr. 2010. Web. 04 Sept. 2012. <http://www.economist.com/node/15879369>.
[2] Margonelli, Lisa. "How Ikea Designs Its Sexy Price Tags." Business 2.0 (October 2002): 106-12. Print.
[3] Hagel, John, and John SSeely Brown. "Learning from Tata's Nano." Businessweek.com. Bloomberg Business Week, 27 Feb. 2008. Web. 4 Sept. 2012. <http://www.businessweek.com/stories/2008-02-27/learning-from-tatas-nanobusinessweek-business-news-stock-market-and-financial-advice>.
[4] "The World Turned Upside down." The Economist. The Economist Newspaper, 15 Apr. 2010. Web. 04 Sept. 2012. <http://www.economist.com/node/15879369>.